Discover · The Research Behind It

Population vs Individual Prediction of Poor Health From Results of Adverse Childhood Experiences Screening — Baldwin et al., JAMA Pediatr 2021

Last checked

  • Free
  • Worldwide
  • Research paper
  • Reading
  • Online
Published in
JAMA Pediatrics, 2021
Evidence
Moderate
Cost
Free.

What is this paper about?

Tested whether ACE scores can tell who will become unwell. In the UK cohort each extra ACE was linked with a 14% higher risk of a mental health problem and 9% of a physical one, yet scores sorted individuals barely better than chance (AUC 0.58 and 0.60; 0.50 is chance). Of children with four or more ACEs, 56% had a mental health problem at 18, against 33% of those with none. The New Zealand cohort gave the same picture.

Why is it in the directory?

Explains how to read ACE research: a high score signals higher risk across a group, not a fixed future for any one person, and screening by ACE score alone is unlikely to target help well. Useful for anyone who has done an online ACE quiz.

Is it free to read?

Two prospective birth cohorts — E-Risk (UK; 2,009 followed to age 18) and Dunedin (New Zealand; 918 followed to age 45). Moderate evidence. JAMA Pediatr 2021;175(4):385–393. DOI 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2020.5602. Free full text in PubMed Central (PMC7835926) — open access, CC BY 4.0.

About the paper

Authors
Baldwin JR, Caspi A, Meehan AJ, et al.
Published in
JAMA Pediatr 2021;175(4):385–393
Kind of study
Two prospective birth cohorts — E-Risk (UK; 2,009 followed to age 18) and Dunedin (New Zealand; 918 followed to age 45)
Strength of evidence
Moderate — good studies, but fewer of them or with some limits
Free to read
CC BY 4.0

Good to know

  • Two cohorts from high-income countries, with health measured at 18 and 45 years, so later-life disease was not covered.

Where it sits in the directory

Listed under “Stress, Trauma & Adversity — How They Are Linked to Chronic Disease” in chapter 17 of the directory, The Research Behind It, with 16 other listings in the same category.

See every listing in “Stress, Trauma & Adversity”

Similar listings

Also in the directory, with why each one is here.

Browse all 280 in The Research Behind It

This page sums up the listing in Notbroken’s own words, from the provider’s own pages; Notbroken does not run it. A listing is not a recommendation, and Notbroken hasn’t tested the service. The details were last checked against the paper and its listing on 25 October 2026. Page first published 7 November 2026. Services, prices and opening hours change, so check with the provider before you rely on them. General information, not medical, legal or financial advice. How these pages work · Run this service? Ask for a change.